MAMH Blog
Massachusetts both second and last in the nation for mental health: A look behind the rankings
Nov 18, 2026
Two reports released this month present differing views of mental health services in the Commonwealth. While rankings may provide an important point of comparison, the real measure of success lies in the lived experience of our residents and their families.
Since 2024, our Commonwealth has held the unenviable distinction of ranking last in the nation for access to in-network behavioral health care. Individuals covered by commercial health plans in Massachusetts are 14 times more likely to seek out-of-network care for behavioral health services (including services provided by both physicians and non-physician providers), than for other medical specialty needs.[1]
The primary driver of this disparity is the inadequate rates of reimbursement for behavioral health services. Massachusetts’ historically low behavioral health reimbursement rates have been documented in national studies for years.[2,3] More recently, the Massachusetts Health Policy Commission reported that commercial insurers reimburse physicians at rates six times higher for 30 minutes of comparable, office-based medical specialty services than rates to physicians for 30 minutes of psychotherapy.[4] Earlier this week, the Association for Behavioral Healthcare (ABH) released a report documenting the effects of rate inadequacies across all payors on long patient wait times, as well as workforce vacancy challenges and financial instability among mental health centers.
Considering these well-documented challenges, Mental Health America’s (MHA) recent ranking of Massachusetts as second best in the nation in its “State of Mental Health in America” report calls for a more critical examination. Our Commonwealth’s efforts to help people and families obtain the behavioral health care they need, when and where they need it, are commendable. The launch of the “Roadmap for Behavioral Health Reform” represents an important investment in expanding access to outpatient and urgent care, and as designed and evident from early implementation, is advancing care in ways that distinguish Massachusetts from other states.
However, while the Commonwealth performs strongly on select measures relative to other states, the MHA composite rating does not capture some important market conditions, which limit our state’s ability to fully respond to all behavioral care needs.
For example, Massachusetts remains highly rated, in part, because of the high number of licensed behavioral health clinicians working in our state. However, these numbers do not necessarily translate into meaningful care access.
Research examining psychiatrists with active medical licenses and addresses in Massachusetts found that half (50%) bill health insurance for only a small number of patients (18 or fewer) on their caseload per year. Less than 10% billed insurance for their full caseload (assuming a mean caseload of 300 patients per full-time provider).
These psychiatrists were also much more likely to bill group commercial insurance than Medicare Advantage, marketplace plans, or Medicaid managed care.[5]
Another MHA measure contributing to the Commonwealth’s high ranking highlights a similarly persistent concern. In Massachusetts, 31.8% of youth were unable to access needed behavioral health care in 2024. Although this rate compares favorably to the much higher national average of 49.3%, nonetheless nearly a third of Massachusetts’ youth remained without care when they were in need.[6]
The ABH report documents yet another worsening trend in access for some youth and families: between 2021 and 2024, the average wait time for an initial assessment at a mental health center increased from 13.6 to 19.1 weeks.[7]
Massachusetts is not alone in its need to improve behavioral health care and access. The “State of Mental Health” report highlights growing rates of uninsurance and rising costs of care nationwide. These barriers underscore the importance of efforts to address affordability, coverage, and parity, which MAMH has prioritized in our legislative and state budget advocacy for decades. Our programs and policy initiatives, including expanding Behavioral Health Urgent Care (BHUC) in Schools and statewide adoption of the Collaborative Care Model, aim to make timely and appropriate behavioral health care accessible to all residents across the Commonwealth.
While rankings may provide an important point of comparison, the real measures of success must be grounded in the daily, lived experience of people with behavioral health needs, their families, and their communities. We urge policymakers to prioritize behavioral health in state budget investments, policy reform, and programmatic innovation, ensuring that progress is measured not simply through rankings but through facts derived from system performance data to account for meaningful advances toward our shared vision of a healthy and resilient Commonwealth for all.
[1] Mark, T. L., & Parish, W. J. (2024). Behavioral health parity – Pervasive disparities in access to in-network care continue. RTI International. Retrieved 2 October 2026 at: https://www.rti.org/publicatio...
[2] Ibid.
[3] Davenport, Gray, & Melek. (2019). Addiction and mental health vs. physical health: Widening disparities in network use and provider reimbursement. Milliman. Retrieved 4 October 2026 at: https://www.milliman.com/en/in...
[4] MA Health Policy Commission. (May 2026.) Examination of Payments for Behavioral Health Care Services. Retrieved 4 October 2026 at: https://masshpc.gov/sites/defa...
[5] Benson, Myong, Newhouse, Fung, & Hsu. (August 2020). Psychiatrist Participation in Private Health Insurance Markets: Paucity in the Land of Plenty. Psychiatric Services, Volume 71, Number 12. Retrieved 17 November 2026 at: https://psychiatryonline.org/d...
[6] Mental Health America. (November 2026). The State of Mental Health in America 2026. Retrieved 17 November 2026 at: https://mhanational.org/the-st...
[7] Association for Behavioral Healthcare. (17 November 2026). Access in Crisis: Outpatient Mental Health Care & Workforce Challenges in Massachusetts Mental Health Centers. Retrieved 17 November 2026 at:
What The Meta Settlement Means for Kids Mental Health in Massachusetts
News
The settlement with states holds promise for youth mental health and well being.
Aging with Pride: LGBTQIA+ Identity, Behavioral Health, and the Importance of Affirming Care
Advocacy Spotlights
Today's LGBTQIA+ older adults lived through decades of resilience, advocacy, and hard-won social change. Yet they also carry experiences of discrimination, stigma, and exclusion that continue to affect behavioral health and well-being.
Legislative Briefing Highlights Need to Transfer Bridgewater State Hospital Oversight
Advocacy
A briefing was held at the State House in June in strong support of bills that require the transfer of Bridgewater State Hospital oversight from the Department of Correction (DOC) to the Department of Mental Health (DMH).
Get important updates on mental health news, events, and advocacy delivered right to your inbox!
Subscribe Now